Valdez v. Duran (New Mexico)

Citing clear evidence that New Mexico public assistance agencies and motor vehicle offices had violated their federally mandated responsibility to offer voter registration opportunities to tens of thousands of New Mexicans each year, Project Vote and its partner voting rights groups filed suit against officials in New Mexico for violations of the National Voter Registration Act of 1993 (NVRA).

Plaintiffs included Celia Valdez, Graciela Grajeda, Jesse Rodriguez, and Shawna Allers. They are all residents of New Mexico that applied for benefits or a driver license or identification, but were denied the opportunity to register to vote or update their registration. The plaintiffs were represented by voting rights groups Project Vote, Dēmos, and the Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law, as well as by the laws firms of Freedman Boyd Hollander Goldberg& Ives, DLA Piper U.S., and Schwartz, Lichten and Bright. Defendants named in the suit include New Mexico’s Secretary of State, Mary Herrera, and officials from the New Mexico Human Services Department, the New Mexico Motor Vehicle Division, and the New Mexico Taxation and Revenue Department.

The complaint alleged that four New Mexico residents were denied the opportunity to register to vote when they went to a state agency to obtain public assistance benefits or obtain a driver’s license or state identification card.

The case was settled in February 2011 after the U.S. District Court ruled that New Mexico’s long-standing policy of distributing voter registration forms only to those public assistance clients who affirmatively ask for them violates the National Voter Registration Act.

In July 2011, New Mexico appealed the U.S. District Court’s ruling, and Project Vote and its partners filed a response brief on September 16, 2011.

On September 23, 2011, the United States Department of Justice filed an amicus brief in support of the District Court ruling. In the brief, the Justice Department asserts that New Mexico’s distribution policy was illegal, and that the plain language and legislative history of the NVRA requires that agencies distribute the voter registration application to clients with every application for benefits, re-certification, and change-of-address.

The plaintiffs won the appeal on February 21, 2012, confirming the District Court’s opinion that public assistance agencies must provide voter registration applications when a client does not decline in writing to receive one.

Most Recent / Relevant Items

Advanced Filters and Sorting

16 results returned

Voter Registration Law Helps Close Disparities in Voter Turnout

Post See all

A recent article in Bloomberg View highlights some of work conducted by Project Vote and our partners to further the implementation and goals of the NVRA. Read more

Letter to New Mexico Secretary of State Duran on Compliance with the NVRA

Publication See all

On October 30, 2014, Project Vote, Demos and the Lawyers Committee for Civil Rights Under Law submitted a letter regarding “Compliance with the National Voter Registration Act” to New Mexico Secretary of State Dianna J. Duran. Read more

Letter to Motor Vehicles Division of New Mexico Taxation and Revenue Dept.

Publication See all

Letter to New Mexico's MVD concerning their obligations under the National Voter Registration Act (NVRA). Read more

Federal Appeals Court Rules That N.M. Violated Federal Law, Failing to Provide Voter Registration Applications to Public Assistance Clients

Press Release See all

The federal Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled yesterday that the State of New Mexico Human Services Department (HSD) violated Section 7 of the National Voter Registration Act of 1993 (NVRA) by improperly withholding voter registration applications from certain public assistance clients. Read more

Valdez v. Duran: Tenth Circuit Court Opinion

Litigation Document See all

Court of Appeals Opinion affirming district court decisions in Valdez v. Duran Read more

Valdez v. Duran: Settlement Agreement

Litigation Document See all

Settlement agreement pertaining to Section 5 (motor vehicle offices) claims in Valdez v. Duran Read more

Federal judge approves NM voting rights settlement

News Item See all

A federal judge has approved a consent order aimed at ensuring New Mexicans have a chance to register to vote at public assistance offices. Read more

New Mexico Settles Lawsuit, Agrees to Offer Voter Registration to Public Assistance Clients

Press Release See all

A federal judge today approved a consent order requiring New Mexico state officials to implement procedures to ensure that thousands of New Mexico citizens have the opportunity to register to vote at state public assistance offices, as provided by the National Voter Registration Act of 1993 (NVRA).  Read more

Agency violates voter registration law

News Item See all

A federal judge has ruled New Mexico's Human Services Department is violating the National Voter Registration Act by not offering a voter registration application with every application for public assistance benefits. Read more

Judge sides with low-income voters:State must hand out forms regardless of whether person requests them

News Item See all

New Mexico must make voter registration easier for thousands of individuals seeking low-income health care benefits, a federal judge said Tuesday. Read more